Linux debugging

Check our new training course

Linux debugging, tracing, profiling & perf. analysis

Check our new training course
with Creative Commons CC-BY-SA
lecture and lab materials

Bootlin logo

Elixir Cross Referencer

	NOEXEC and NOFORK applets.

Unix shells traditionally execute some commands internally in the attempt
to dramatically speed up execution. It will be slow as hell if for every
"echo blah" shell will fork and exec /bin/echo. To this end, shells
have to _reimplement_ these commands internally.

Busybox is unique in this regard because it already is a collection
of reimplemented Unix commands, and we can do the same trick
for speeding up busybox shells, and more. NOEXEC and NOFORK applets
are exactly those applets which are eligible for these tricks.

Applet will be subject to NOFORK/NOEXEC tricks only if it is marked
as such in applets.src.h or in their inline "//applet:" directives.

In C, if you want to call a program and wait for it, use
spawn_and_wait(argv), BB_EXECVP(prog,argv) or BB_EXECLP(prog,argv0,...).
They check whether program name is an applet name and optionally
do NOFORK/NOEXEC thing depending on configuration.


	Relevant CONFIG options

FEATURE_PREFER_APPLETS
  Globally enables NOFORK/NOEXEC tricks for such programs as xargs
  and find:
  BB_EXECVP(cmd, argv) will try to exec /proc/self/exe
  if command's name matches some applet name;
  spawn_and_wait(argv) will do NOFORK/NOEXEC tricks

//TODO: the above two things probably should have separate options?

FEATURE_SH_STANDALONE
  shells will try to exec /proc/self/exe if command's name matches
  some applet name; shells will do NOEXEC trick on NOEXEC applets

//TODO: split (same as for PREFER_APPLETS)

FEATURE_SH_NOFORK
  shells will do NOFORK trick on NOFORK applets

NB: shell builtins use these tricks regardless of FEATURE_SH_STANDALONE,
FEATURE_PREFER_APPLETS or FEATURE_SH_NOFORK. In effect, builtins
are "always NOFORK".


	NOEXEC

NOEXEC applet should work correctly if another applet forks and then
executes exit(<applet>_main(argc,argv)) in the child. The rules
roughly are:

* do not expect shared global variables/buffers to be in their
  "initialized" state. Examples: xfunc_error_retval can be != 1,
  bb_common_bufsiz1 can be scribbled over, ...
  (although usually xfunc_error_retval's state is not a problem).
* do not expect that stdio wasn't used before. Calling set[v]buf()
  can be disastrous.
* ...

NOEXEC applets save only one half of fork+exec overhead.
NOEXEC trick is disabled for NOMMU build.


	NOFORK

NOFORK applet should work correctly if another applet simply runs
<applet>_main(argc,argv) and then continues with its business.
xargs, find, shells do it (grep for "spawn_and_wait" and
"run_nofork_applet" to find more users).

This poses much more serious limitations on what applet can do:

* all NOEXEC limitations apply.
* do not run for a long time or wait for user input:
  hush shell only handles signals (like ^C) after you return
  from APPLET_main().
* do not ever exit() or exec().
  - xfuncs are okay. They are using special trick to return
    to the caller applet instead of dying when they detect "x" condition.
  - you may "exit" to caller applet by calling xfunc_die(). Return value
    is taken from xfunc_error_retval.
  - fflush_stdout_and_exit(n) is ok to use.
* do not use shared global data, or save/restore shared global data
  (e.g. bb_common_bufsiz1) prior to returning.
  - getopt32() is ok to use. You do not need to save/restore option_mask32,
    xfunc_error_retval, and logmode - it is already done by core code.
* if you allocate memory, you can use xmalloc() only on the very first
  allocation. All other allocations should use malloc[_or_warn]().
  After first allocation, you cannot use any xfuncs.
  Otherwise, failing xfunc will return to caller applet
  without freeing malloced data!
* the same applies to other resources, such as open fds: no xfuncs after
  acquiring them!
* All allocated data, opened files, signal handlers, termios settings
  etc should be freed/closed/restored prior to return.

Currently, ash shell signal handling is implemented in a way that signals
have non-SA_RESTARTed handlers. This means that system calls can
return EINTR. An example of such problem is "yes" applet:
it is implemented so that it has a writing loop, this loop is exited on
any write error, and in the case of user pressing ^C the error was EINTR.
The problem is, the error causes stdout FILE* object to get into error
state, needing clearerr() - or else subsequent shell output will also
not work. ("yes" has been downgraded to NOEXEC, since hush signal handling
does not have this problem - which makes "yes" to not exit on ^C (bug).
But stray EINTRs can be seen in any NOFORK under ash, until ash is fixed).

NOFORK applets give the most of speed advantage, but are trickiest
to implement. In order to minimize amount of bugs and maintenance,
prime candidates for NOFORK-ification are those applets which
are small and easy to audit, and those which are more likely to be
frequently executed from shell/find/xargs, particularly in shell
script loops. Applets which mess with signal handlers, termios etc
are probably not worth the effort.

Applets which must be interruptible by ^C in shells can not be NOFORKs.

Any NOFORK applet is also a NOEXEC applet.


	Calling NOFORK applets

API to call NOFORK applets is two functions:

	run_nofork_applet(appno, argv)
	spawn_and_wait(argv) // only if FEATURE_PREFER_APPLETS=y

First one is directly used by shells if FEATURE_SH_NOFORK=y.
Second one is used by many applets, but main users are xargs and find.
It itself calls run_nofork_applet(), if argv[0] is a name
of a NOFORK applet.

run_nofork_applet() saves/inits/restores option parsing, xfunc_error_retval,
logmode, applet_name. Thus, for example, caller does not need to worry about
option_mask32 getting trashed.


	Calling NOEXEC applets

It's the same trusty spawn_and_wait(argv). If FEATURE_PREFER_APPLETS=y,
it does NOEXEC trick. It resets xfunc_error_retval = 1 and
logmode = LOGMODE_STDIO in the child.